Why Technique trumps Fitness in Swimming
Ever wondered why when you compare your times for a 100 m all-out sprint vs a 100 m at your regular pace you are only able to shave off a few seconds? All that extra effort and so little to show for it! What is holding you back – is it swim fitness, or drag, or an inefficient pull? Let’s look at the math (or you can ignore the math and just read the conclusions)
For a swimmer swimming at a steady speed, the forward thrust force developed by the swimmer is equal to the drag force holding the swimmer back.
The thrust you can generate is dependent on your stroke rate and stroke efficiency and the drag force is dependent on factors such as frontal area, drag coefficient (combined in a constant c) and your speed (v).
Using these formulae, we can determine how much extra power you need to deploy to reduce your 100 m time from 2:00 min to 1:00 min assuming your technique does not change (let’s say you just increase stroke rate without improving efficiency or reducing drag):
You need to develop 8x more power to go 2x as fast and as Work= Power x time this corresponds to 4x the work. A lot of training would be required to increase your swimming FTP by 8x!. The bottom line is that you won’t see big speed gains if you just focus on swim fitness.
But what if you could cut your drag in half by say........ not crossing over, swimming more horizontally and eliminating the scissor kick. How much faster could you swim for the same power output (swim fitness level)?
Halving your drag increases your speed by 26% for no extra effort - free speed just like on the bike! Reducing drag can bring significant speed gains independent of swim fitness.
Now, what if you could increase the efficiency of your pull, by working on your catch and increasing the effective length of your pull and this resulted in 2x the F(thrust)? How much faster (v2) would you go if the drag stayed the same?
Doubling the forward propulsion from your pull increases your speed by 41%! Note that the speed does not double because drag increases exponentially with speed. The power required also has to increase, but only by 2.8x and some of this could come from efficiency gains rather than fitness gains. Let us now assume you had a really awesome coach and they were able to take you, a 2:00 min/100 m swimmer, and both halve your effective drag and double your forward thrust by improving your technique. How fast would you go?
This is twice as fast, i.e. 1:00 min/100 m! Now of course this speed gain requires more power to achieve (about 4x) but much less than the 8x needed if you did nothing to improve stroke efficiency and reduce drag. Although swim fitness is important, especially for endurance events, technique improvements to optimize catch and pull efficiency and reduce drag will bring bigger gains in performance. Relying solely on swim fitness improvements alone to gain speed is not a winning strategy – take some lessons to improve your technique!
The correct pacing, however, is an important part of a winning strategy. Consider an athlete who starts out fast at 125% of their endurance pace for the first quarter of an IM swim leg, then tires and slows down to 75% for the next 2 quarters. Recovered and anticipating the finish line the swimmer increases the pace to 125% for the remaining quarter. The average pace for the swim leg is 100% of the athlete’s endurance pace. However, it can easily be shown that the average power required is about 1.19x the power required to complete the swim at a constant pace of 100% of endurance pace. This is because power requirements increase exponentially with speed. The power costs of the pace increase at the start and end of the swim leg are not balanced by the power savings resulting from the slower pace over quarters 2 and 3. Indeed, for the same 1.19x higher power output had the swimmer maintained a constant pace that pace would have been 6% faster – saving about 3:30 min from a 1 hr IM swim for example. The fastest way to swim is to hold a constant pace and learning to maintain your maximum endurance pace should be an important part of your training.
Phew....that was a lot of information. Whether you read the full article or jumped to the conclusion, I'm sure your next question is, how can I take this information and implement it into my training to improve my technique? This is where Team Triumph comes in.
We have just launched a NEW program - Mastering the High Elbow Catch (2 session course).
This 2-lesson private course reveals the simple steps you can take to begin to master the elusive high elbow catch. We use an approach unique to Team Triumph that explains why and teaches you how. It involves both real-time visuals using mirrors in the pool and video feedback. This course is recommended for experienced swimmers who are looking to break through to the next level of swim efficiency.
I will be conducting this course. To find out more information about me as a Coach you can visit our website
Let me help you break through to the next level in your swimming. Send an email to info@pbest.ca to book a session.
If you are not ready for this course but are still looking for help with your swimming, we have other options available. We have private swim lessons with video analysis which is different than our new course and without a video analysis.
We also offer Private Coaching for those looking for a more personal coaching experience. You can find this information on our website.
Send us an email to info@pbest.ca to book a session.
Kevin Willis
NCCP Triathlon Adult Community Coach
Team Triumph Triathlon Club
I love the accountability and the structure of the Virtual 70.3 Half Ironman training program. I don't think I would have gotten this far without the program. The accountability is huge for me!
Deborah Jackman
My coach Kevin Willis is amazing. His swim practices have been a real game-changer for me. A great communicator regardless of your swim level. The whole club is supportive of everything you do. You don't need to be an Ironman to benefit from their programs. 5 stars all around!!! - Denise Pittuck
I just wanted to thank you and your team (Gabi! Brenda! Maggie! Dawn!) for making last weekend's event so amazing. I had tried to do a try-a-tri on my own last summer, and the experience was night and day.
Even though I didn't make every virtual session, I felt so prepared... I knew where to go for information, and I knew I had a team of people (coaches and our beginner tri group!) who were all there to support me.
It was interesting to watch Eric train on his own (without access to the TrainingPeaks workouts and without the weekly meetings to ask questions and learn more about proper form and race-day stuff). When we left on Sunday, he looked at me and was like "we're DEFINITELY doing the training with Julia if we decide to go for the olympic distance, right?".
So glad to have found this club and looking forward to many more triathlons in the near future!!! Tai Teleso
Julia is incredible, I once had a coach who told me to get good at biking and running as he couldn't do anything with my swim technique. Then I was introduced to Julia who is so patient and has an amazing ability to translate it all into a way I could understand. I knocked a minute per 100m off my open water swim times after only a handful of sessions with her. The team is also really welcoming, inclusive and most of all FUN!
Triumph is a warm and fun place for every level of triathlete. Whether you’re just getting started and learning all about triathlon or have been at it for decades, like some of us, you will find camaraderie and expertise in this group with Julia Aimers’ support and caring. She keeps up-to-date in so many areas of training, especially for women and including women’s issues whether it be nutrition or menopause. I highly recommend Team Triumph for swimming, biking, running or putting it all together in one package. There is no other place or group, I would rather be training with. So many of my close friends were met in this group.
A huge thank you to my Triathlon coach, Julia Cooper-Aimers. She took the time last week to drop off (from a distance because of COVID19 restrictions) some tri shorts I ordered along with a well-appreciated note to remind me that there will be ups and downs and that things will get better. She has gone above and beyond to support all of her athletes and our Team Triumph club, by providing almost daily strength, yoga, and spinning videos that have been uploaded to Youtube for anyone who needs a little motivation during these challenging times as well as many words of encouragement. I am grateful for her support and encouragement. ❤️
Anita Lacelle Taylor
Training with Team Triumph for 7 months (so far) made me faster and stronger while building nourishing connections with like-minded fitness nuts and shattering the expectations I had of myself. TT is a crew of inspiring people pursuing epic individual goals and encouraging each other along the way. Julia and her team have expert knowledge and provide a thoughtful evidence-based group program that works. I am privileged and thankful to have Team Triumph in my neighborhood and can't wait to get back to the pool!
Alex Bourne
I want to thank you for always putting our well-being at the forefront of your business model. You suspended face-to-face programs in a timely manner, leading the way in a fitness business world that took much too long to respond and put their members’ health and the community at risk. You « triumphed « in quickly acting to flatten the curve.
Your caring nature resulted in a series of innovative and fun virtual sessions and opened them to the community. I am missing the live interaction now that I am working for a few months but I appreciate that I can access the videos according to my schedule. Yin/yang session tonight, just what I needed.
Not to mention the check-ins, the home deliveries, the charitable events. Priceless.
Simone Rose-Oliver